Couldn't Be Fairer

Clip 1: Discovery is just a word

2 min 39 sec ( skip to teachers’ notes)

Taken from the documentary Couldn't Be Fairer (1984)

Original title classification M – this clip chosen to be PG

Teachers’ notes

provided by The Le@rning Federation

This page is printer friendly

This clip shows black-and-white archival footage of Indigenous Australians engaged in traditional ceremonial activities, building a shelter, fishing with spears and collecting food. This footage includes narration by Aboriginal activist Mick Miller, who details the treatment of Indigenous people since Australia was colonised by the British in 1788. The second half of the clip shows footage of Indigenous people on a Christian mission in the 1930s. The original narration, included with this footage, claims that the missions are giving Indigenous people ‘the benefits of civilisation’ and includes the intertitle ‘Happy halfcaste girls in the orphanage’.

Educational value points

• Miller says Indigenous Australians have a deep spiritual affinity with the land and refers to the land as ‘the source of all life and meaning to us’. During Dreaming, the creation time, it is believed that spirit ancestors travelled across the land, setting out laws for Aboriginal social and spiritual behaviour and creating the natural environment, which Indigenous people then became a part of. Indigenous language groups belong to different homelands. The land sustains them and in return they have a sacred duty to protect it. Indigenous identity is derived from this stewardship and the ongoing connection it provides to Dreaming.

• In the 1930s the Australian Government adopted a policy of assimilating Indigenous Australians. From the 1870s Indigenous people had been increasingly housed on reserves and missions. According to an academic, James Jupp, until the 1930s it was believed that Indigenous Australians were a ‘vanishing race’, but when this proved to be incorrect the Government adopted a policy of assimilation. This was to be achieved by instructing Indigenous Australians in a Western way of life.

• Government reserves and church-run missions were set up to protect the welfare of Indigenous people. In this period a Western way of life was defined as ‘civilised’ and superior to Indigenous culture, which was seen as ‘primitive’. Thus, assimilation was viewed as a way of improving Indigenous welfare. Many Indigenous people were taken to missions or reserves, where they were often discouraged from using their languages or cultural practices and were introduced to Christianity. A consequence of the confinement of Indigenous people to these settlements was that their tribal land could more easily be occupied by settlers.

• Under the policy of assimilation, up to one in three Indigenous children were forcibly removed from their families and communities. These children were taken to church or state institutions such as the orphanage shown in this clip or raised by non-Indigenous families. The Government believed that children with light skin or of mixed European and Indigenous descent could be absorbed into mainstream society through acculturation and intermarriage. Children who were removed from their families for this reason are known as the Stolen Generations.

• The removal of Indigenous people from their lands denied them access to traditional sources of food, and as a result the Government distributed rations that included refined flour, sugar, tinned or salted meat and tea. At some reserves and missions the rations were of poor quality, were nutritionally inadequate and did not include fresh fruit and vegetables. A poor diet was not restricted to the missions. The Great Depression of the 1930s left large numbers of the Australian population with little money for a balanced diet.

• Because British settlers did not recognise the land ownership system of Indigenous Australians and so declared Australia to be ‘terra nullius’ (land with no legal owner), as Miller says, Indigenous Australians became ‘marginal people in our own country’. Indigenous people who resisted this settlement were sometimes shot, arrested and kept in chains and in some cases their waterholes were poisoned. In 1992 the High Court overturned ‘terra nullius’ in the Mabo (No 2) judgement. Land rights legislation had been passed in various states and territories in the 1960s and 70s but the Mabo judgement recognised an inherent right to the land, arising out of Indigenous law and custom.

• The original narration heard in this clip is indicative of the cultural blindness of the time to the complexity of Indigenous culture or its longevity, with Indigenous Australians being seen as ‘primitive’ and childlike, and needing to be civilised and protected. The camera focuses on a woman being dressed in European clothing as if such garments represent ‘civilisation’. The positioning of Indigenous Australians as ‘other’ is demonstrated through the use of dehumanising language, for example, referring to Indigenous men as ‘bucks’ and children as ‘piccaninnies’.

• A belief in the superiority of Western culture shaped attitudes towards Indigenous Australians and informed government policy in the 1930s when this footage was taken. This belief was behind the policy of assimilation that was pursued by the Government until the 1960s. In the archival footage the commentator reinforces the assumption that the welfare of Indigenous people will be improved by introducing them to a Western way of life. He concludes that ‘the good work of the Sacred Heart missionaries turns the primitive people into a happy healthy community’.

Clip downloads

This clip can also be downloaded as an MP4 file.

search

full texttitle

• Titles
  • Feature films
  • Documentaries
  • Television programs
  • Short films
  • Home movies
  • Newsreels
  • Advertisements
  • Other historical footage
  • Sponsored films
  • Short features
  • Indigenous content
• Education
• Other content
• Accessibility statement

Partners